Philadelphia's pizza story runs deeper than a slice. Tomato pie, grandma squares, wood-fired Neapolitan, and the corner stromboli all have a place here. This list covers eleven spots across the city, from a Manayunk stalwart to an Old City counter, ranked by the public record.
Compare all 11 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
The Tomato Shack has been a Manayunk fixture long enough that returning visitors find it unchanged, which is the point. The dough and house tomato sauce are the foundation, and the 16-inch craft-your-own is the move for groups. Seating runs both inside and out. The kitchen keeps things fresh, though diners who want a heavier cheese pull should note that the ratio leans toward the crust and sauce side.
What to order
Craft Your Own Pizza, House Tomato Sauce Pizza, 16-inch Specialty Pizza
102 Rector St, Philadelphia, PA 19127 · (215) 483-2233
Wilder works as a neighborhood stop when the occasion is low-key, a drink and a slice before the train or a casual round with the group. The happy-hour window draws regulars who live within walking distance. Seating across two floors, with the first floor catching drafts when the door traffic picks up. The pizza and salads are solid without demanding attention, which is exactly what a convenient neighborhood room should deliver.
What to order
Sweet and spicy pizza, Pasta, Oysters
2009 Sansom St, Philadelphia, PA 19103 · (215) 309-2149
Chick's is not primarily a pizza room, but the menu has enough range to hold a table together. The garlic Parm wings are consistently called out as among the better wings in the neighborhood. Mussels in white wine and a crispy chicken sandwich round out the order for a group that can't agree. Outdoor seating is available. The room runs full-service and handles mixed-appetite crowds without drama.
What to order
Garlic Parm wings, Crispy chicken sandwich, Mussels in white wine
1807 Washington Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19146 · (215) 546-2233
OG Pizza is where the thin-crust pie and the cheesesteak platter share equal billing, and the portions are large enough that the price point at the dollar-sign level looks even better. The calzones are substantial. The cheesesteaks and hoagies draw their own regulars separate from the pizza crowd. Chicken parm and pepperoni are the reliable pie orders. The room skews casual and quick, not lingering.
What to order
Cheesesteak platter, Calzone, Pepperoni pizza
2500 Frankford Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19125 · (215) 634-7667
Wood Street is a downtown slice shop, counter-service and no-frills, with a few tables and a standing area for those eating on the move. The thin crust comes out crispy and hot. Mushroom and spinach is a regular combination here. Calzones and pasta round out the menu for those who want more than a slice. The shop handles the late-night and the sober lunch crowd with equal consistency, which is a reliable sign.
What to order
Thin crust pizza slice, Calzone, Pasta
325 N 12th St, Philadelphia, PA 19107, United States · (215) 515-3382
Jake's and Cooper's is the higher-end Manayunk option on this list, a wine bar with a full kitchen. The spicy meatball pizza and gnocchi draw the most notice from the dining room. Parmesan fries and a well-stocked wine list, including orange wine, make it useful for a birthday or a celebration where someone at the table cares about what's in the glass. Service has drawn mixed notes; the kitchen is stronger than the floor on off nights.
What to order
Gnocchi, Spicy Meatball Pizza, Parmesan Fries
4365 Main St, Philadelphia, PA 19127 · (215) 483-0444
Stogie Joe's is cash-only, and that detail sorts the crowd before the door opens. The room runs late, draws locals, and keeps it straightforward: beers on tap, crab fries that hold up, and a pasta special that gets called out specifically. Burger is on the menu. It is busy on weekends, the kind of place that is teeming on a Saturday regardless of the hour. Bring cash.
Stogie Joe's Tavern is a neighborhood bar first and a restaurant second, and that ordering is the whole point. The room draws a steady local crowd at hours when most kitchens have already shut down, and the line of customers out front on a Saturday night says more about the place than any menu description could. This is not a destination for the tourist dragging a cheesesteak map; it is a spot for the person who already knows the block. The crab fries are the thing to start with. They come out hot and loaded, and they read as the signature move the kitchen has built its late-night reputation on.
The pasta special changes, but it has earned consistent attention from the people who eat here regularly; when it lands right, it justifies the trip on its own. The burger rounds out the short list of plates worth ordering, straightforward and satisfying in the way a bar burger should be. The beer taps are well-tended and the list is solid for a neighborhood tavern. The service operates at the pace the room demands: fast when it needs to be, comfortable when it does not. Cash only is a firm policy, so arriving without bills means a trip to the ATM, not a workaround at the bar.
Moderately priced throughout, Stogie Joe's runs as a genuinely local operation in a city that still prizes that kind of room. South Philly has its share of red-gravy institutions and East Passyunk has the BYOB date-night crowd; Stogie Joe's is the other layer, the corner tavern that keeps the lights on past midnight and feeds the neighborhood when the neighborhood needs it. Plan around the cash requirement and arrive knowing what to order.
Insider tip
The crab fries are the anchor order; get them first. Bring cash, no exceptions, and check whether the pasta special is running before committing to anything else on the menu.
Clarkville offers indoor and outdoor seating and a menu that puts salads on equal footing with the pies. The beer salad with cheese is a regular order. The moussaka pie and loaded veggie pie are the signature options, though some diners find the toppings light for the price. Salads come in generous portions. The service has drawn inconsistent notes, and the greens have occasionally arrived past their best. Order the pizza and the salad, keep expectations calibrated.
What to order
Beer Salad, Moussaka Pie, Loaded Veggie Pie
4301 Baltimore Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19104 · (215) 387-4992
Slices runs a broader menu than the name suggests. The stromboli is large, a wait comes with it, and a medium is the practical call for fewer than four people. The cheesesteak has built its own following separate from the pizza side, with regulars tracking improvement over time. Mozzarella sticks and jalapeño poppers work as starters. The price point is low, the portions are not.
What to order
Stromboli, Cheesesteak, Mozzarella Sticks
4249 Ridge Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19129 · (215) 843-4747
Lazos is a neighborhood pizza-and-grill spot where the pepperoni and plain pies are the reliable order. Both come out fresh and hot when the kitchen is on. The cheesesteak gets ordered but the pizza is the better reason to be here, and regulars say so plainly. Quesadillas and other grill items have drawn less consistent notes. Keep the order to the pizza and the experience tracks.
What to order
Pepperoni pizza, Plain pizza, Cheesesteak
2533 Poplar St, Philadelphia, PA 19130 · (215) 236-2300
Old City Pizza does grandma-style pizza and tomato pie from a counter-service setup in a neighborhood that mostly runs tourist traffic. The tomato pie is the local thing to order here, square, sauce forward, the way it is supposed to be. The grandma pizza pulls a home-cooked quality that stands apart from the slice-shop competition nearby. Fast for to-go orders. The counter staff draws consistent praise for making the room feel like a neighborhood spot, not a landmark.
What to order
Grandma pizza, Cheese pizza, Tomato pie
100 N 3rd St, Philadelphia, PA 19106 · (215) 574-9494
It depends on the neighborhood. This guide covers spots from Manayunk to Old City to downtown. Each restaurant's Insider Score reflects the aggregated public review record, and no restaurant pays to be listed, so the rankings are based on what diners actually report.
What makes Philadelphia tomato pie different from regular pizza?
Tomato pie is square, sauce goes on top of the cheese rather than under it, and it is often served at room temperature. It is a South Philly and Philadelphia-area tradition. Old City Pizza on this list serves a version worth knowing.
Are any of these pizza spots good for groups?
Several are. OG Pizza, Slices Pizza, and Chick's are called out specifically for handling groups, with large portions and a range of items on the menu. Wilder and Jake's and Cooper's also work for larger parties, the latter with a wine list to match.
How does Top of Philly rank these restaurants?
Rankings are based on the Insider Score, which aggregates the public review record. No restaurant pays for placement or a higher score. The guide reflects what diners report, not sponsored picks or personal visits by the editorial team.
The data first, then the verdict
We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →
Sal Lombardi covers the Philadelphia sandwich and the South Philly Italian-American table for Top of Philly: cheesesteaks, roast pork, hoagies, the Italian Market, and the red-gravy institutions.