Top of Philly

Philadelphia / Guides / American
The Guide · American

American in Philadelphia: 12 Local Favorites (2026)

Twelve restaurants across Philadelphia. Compare neighborhoods, price tiers and what to order, then read the full reviews.

M
By Margaret Donnelly Chief Critic · Updated September 2026 · How the score is built
American in Philadelphia: 12 Local Favorites (2026)
THE PHILADELPHIA DINING GUIDES 12 restaurants
Compare all 12 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreWhat to order
01 ZahavPhiladelphia$$$$9.9Hummus
02 The DandelionPhiladelphia$$$8.4Fish and chips
03 Yards Brewing CompanyPhiladelphia$$6.6Yards IPA
04 The Continental Mid-townPhiladelphia$$4.2Bloody Mary
05 McGillin's Olde Ale HousePhiladelphia$$4.5Fish and chips
06 The Twisted TailPhiladelphia$$4.8Bourbon flight
07 Penrose DinerPhiladelphia$$4.8Euro sandwich
08 Helium Comedy ClubPhiladelphia$$3.3Chicken tenders
09 Oregon DinerPhiladelphia$$3.7Eggs and breakfast plate
10 Liberty Bell DinerPhiladelphia$$3.7Mozzarella sticks
11 Bake'n Bacon PhiladelphiaPhiladelphia4.6Bacon sandwich
12 Live! Casino & Hotel PhiladelphiaPhiladelphia$$2.5Prime rib

12 restaurants · In guide order

1 Zahav Yelp

Zahav

Mediterranean · Philadelphia · $$$$
Insider Score9.9

Michael Solomonov's James Beard Award-winning room on Society Hill remains the standard by which Philadelphia special-occasion dining is measured. The hummus alone justifies the reservation, the salatim arrive in waves, and the slow-roasted lamb shoulder is the kind of dish that defines a kitchen's reputation. Portions are genuinely generous for a tasting-format room. Books out; plan ahead.

What to orderHummusLamb shoulderSalatim Book a table Call Directions
Full review & visiting detailsRead the full review & visiting details

Michael Solomonov's Modern Israeli Landmark Earns Its Place

Hummus

The long-cooked, tahini-forward hummus is the kitchen's calling card at this James Beard Award, winning BYOB, ordered by nearly every table.

Lamb shoulder

The wood-roasted lamb shoulder anchors the tasting menu and draws the most consistent praise from the dining room.

Salatim

The rotating salatim spreads open the meal, signaling the depth of the modern Israeli kitchen before the main courses arrive.

Zahav is the room that put modern Israeli cooking on the national map, and after more than a decade the kitchen under Michael Solomonov still operates at a level that justifies the reservation difficulty. The prix-fixe structure anchors everything: the meal opens with salatim, a spread of small vegetable preparations that set the register for what follows, then proceeds through mezze before arriving at the large-format proteins. The hummus here is the standard against which most of the city's other versions get measured, smooth and warm, served with fresh laffa, and genuinely hard to stop eating. It earns that reputation through technique, not through portion size alone, though the portions throughout are notably generous for a tasting-format room at this price tier.

The lamb shoulder, slow-roasted and served whole for the table, is the anchor dish: it has the kind of fall-apart texture and depth of flavor that makes the high-end price feel like a transaction fairly struck. The salatim course, easily overlooked on paper, is where the kitchen demonstrates its range, rotating preparations that reflect both Israeli culinary tradition and seasonal sourcing. The room itself is small and fills quickly; this is a books-out restaurant, and the reservations reflect it. Service operates with the efficiency a full-turn high-covers room requires, though accounts suggest it reads as attentive rather than mechanical.

For Philadelphia dining occasions, Zahav sits in the special-occasion tier alongside a handful of other nationally recognized rooms, but unlike some expense-account destinations it draws a crowd that runs young and genuinely enthusiastic alongside the celebration-dinner regulars. The price is high-end by any measure; the cooking, on the evidence of the record, holds up its end.

Map showing Zahav© OpenStreetMap
HoursMon: ClosedTue - Sat: 5:00 PM - 9:30 PMSun: Closed
Address237 St James Pl
Philadelphia, PA, 19106
Insider tip

The lamb shoulder is the signature large-format dish and the reason to book a full table rather than two; the hummus course arrives early and is worth restraint, because the meal builds considerably from there.

2 The Dandelion Yelp

The Dandelion

American · Philadelphia · $$$
Insider Score8.4

A Stephen Starr gastropub occupying a handsome building near Rittenhouse Square, The Dandelion earns its reputation on the fish and chips, which hold up against the British pub standard the room is reaching for. The shepherd's pie and beef burger round out a menu that plays it straight. Outdoor seating works well when the weather cooperates. The birthday-dinner crowd keeps returning for a reason.

What to orderFish and chipsBeef burgerShepherd's pie Book a table Call Directions
Full review & visiting detailsRead the full review & visiting details

A Historic Pub Playing It Straight

The Dandelion trades on the English gastropub template, and it earns the comparison on craft rather than costume. Fish and chips anchor the menu, and the record points to a kitchen that treats the fry as a technique worth getting right rather than a bar-food afterthought, the batter shattering clean instead of going soggy under malt vinegar. The beef burger sits alongside it as the room's other reliable order, built for a crowd that wants something familiar done with real attention rather than reinvented.

Shepherd's pie rounds out the trio and does the heaviest cultural lifting, a dish that only works if the kitchen respects the long-braise logic underneath the mashed topping, and its presence on a Philadelphia menu says the place is more interested in the English pub tradition than in chasing a trend. The building itself is historic, and the interior leans into that with a gastropub register: dark wood, a sense of permanence, the kind of room that reads as established rather than staged for an opening month. Outdoor seating extends the footprint in warm weather, giving the room a second identity as a patio destination once the season turns.

The occasion the room keeps earning is the birthday dinner, and that tracks: it is a menu built for a table that wants to celebrate without gambling on something unfamiliar, and a room with enough polish to feel like an event without tipping into formality. Pricing sits at the upscale end for pub food, which puts The Dandelion in competition less with the corner tavern and more with the city's broader new-American rooms, and the fish and chips and shepherd's pie are doing the work of justifying that gap. This is not a BYOB and it is not chasing the tasting-menu tier; it is a full-service pub kitchen with a historic address and a menu that plays it straight, which in a city full of chef-driven ambition counts as its own kind of confidence.

Map showing The Dandelion© OpenStreetMap
HoursMon - Thu: 11:30 AM - 11:00 PMFri: 11:30 AM - 12:00 AMSat: 10:00 AM - 12:00 AMSun: 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Address124 S 18th St
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Insider tip

Order the fish and chips if it is a first visit, save the shepherd's pie for cooler months when the braise makes more sense, and ask for the outdoor tables on a clear day since the patio turns over fast once word gets around.

3 Yards Brewing Company Yelp

Yards Brewing Company

American · Philadelphia · $$
Insider Score6.6

Yards is the Philadelphia brewery that stayed in the city when others left, and the taproom reflects that commitment. The IPA and the Brawler Amber Ale are the anchors; the soft pretzel with beer cheese is the right food choice at a pint stop. Parking on site, which is not nothing in this city. The room runs group-friendly and casual; arrive before any large organized event claims the floor.

What to orderYards IPABrawler Amber AlePretzel with beer cheese Call Directions Scored from the full review record 500 Spring Garden St, Philadelphia, PA 19123 · (215) 525-0175
4 The Continental Mid-town Yelp

The Continental Mid-town

American · Philadelphia · $$
Insider Score4.2

The Continental Mid-town is a Stephen Starr production in Rittenhouse Square that wears a retro-diner skin over a modern menu. The Bloody Mary is a reliable opener for a weekend lunch, and the grilled burger and roasted chicken hold the center of a menu built for lingering. The room draws a lively crowd during neighborhood events. Service can be uneven, but the kitchen keeps its footing.

What to orderBloody MaryGrilled burgerRoasted chicken Call Directions Scored from the full review record 1801 Chestnut St, Philadelphia, PA 19103 · (215) 567-1800
5 McGillin's Olde Ale House Yelp

McGillin's Olde Ale House

American · Philadelphia · $$
Insider Score4.5

McGillin's has been open since 1860, which makes it the oldest continuously operating tavern in Philadelphia. The fish and chips, shepherd's pie, and Guinness stew are the workhorses of a menu that does not pretend to be anything other than classic pub food. The bartenders are a draw in their own right. Decorated for every holiday, reliably crowded, and exactly what a Center City institution should be.

What to orderFish and chipsShepherd's pieGuinness stew Call Directions Scored from the full review record 1310 Drury St, Philadelphia, PA 19107 · (215) 735-5562
6 The Twisted Tail Yelp

The Twisted Tail

American · Philadelphia · $$
Insider Score4.8

The Twisted Tail on South Street carries one of the deeper bourbon selections in the city, and the happy hour pricing makes that selection more accessible than it has any right to be. The comfort food runs honest and filling. The room has a saloon character, live music on the schedule, and a bar program that the kitchen supports without overshadowing. Bourbon drinkers should note the flight options.

What to orderBourbon flightComfort food platterHappy hour bites Call Directions Scored from the full review record 509 S 2nd St, Philadelphia, PA 19147 · (215) 558-2471
7 Penrose Diner Yelp

Penrose Diner

American · Philadelphia · $$
Insider Score4.8

The Penrose is South Philly diner culture in its clearest form: sandwiches built on the Euro and roast beef models, soup and salad, and a room that has been feeding the neighborhood for generations. Brunch and lunch are the moves here. Service is efficient and the kitchen handles takeout without complaint. The kind of place a neighborhood produces and then refuses to give up.

What to orderEuro sandwichRoast beef sandwichSoup and salad Call Directions Scored from the full review record 2016 Penrose Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19145 · (215) 465-1097
8 Helium Comedy Club Yelp

Helium Comedy Club

American · Philadelphia · $$
Insider Score3.3

Helium is Philadelphia's most consistent comedy-club operation, with a booking record that pulls national acts and a room that has worked out the logistics over years of use. Tickets are will-call by default; the ID check at entry is standard. Chicken tenders and loaded nachos are the practical food choices. Couples and groups return on a regular rotation. The experience is what the format promises.

What to orderChicken tendersLoaded nachosCraft beer Call Directions Scored from the full review record 2031 Sansom St, Philadelphia, PA 19103 · (215) 496-9001
9 Oregon Diner Yelp

Oregon Diner

American · Philadelphia · $$
Insider Score3.7

Oregon Diner is a South Philly institution that runs fast and runs full. The breakfast plate, pancakes, and home fries are the draws; portions are large and the kitchen keeps food hot. The room stays busy, but seating turns over quickly enough that waits rarely punish. For South Philly residents, this is the diner they grew up with, and the kitchen maintains the standard that reputation requires.

What to orderEggs and breakfast platePancakesHome fries Call Directions Scored from the full review record 302 Oregon Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19148 · (215) 462-5566
10 Liberty Bell Diner Yelp

Liberty Bell Diner

American · Philadelphia · $$
Insider Score3.7

Liberty Bell Diner operates at the reliable end of the Philadelphia diner spectrum: the mozzarella sticks have earned specific notice, the fettuccine Alfredo is a comfort-food staple, and the turkey dinner is a full-plate proposition. The kitchen runs all hours without a significant drop in consistency. A neighborhood regular's room, not a destination, but the kind of place that holds a block together.

What to orderMozzarella sticksFettuccine AlfredoTurkey dinner Call Directions Scored from the full review record 8445 Frankford Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19136 · (215) 331-4344
11 Bake'n Bacon Philadelphia Yelp

Bake'n Bacon Philadelphia

American · Philadelphia
Insider Score4.6

Bake'n Bacon Philadelphia leads with its bacon sandwich and backs it with caramel fries that the kitchen takes seriously enough to add house caramel sauce on request. A vegan sandwich option extends the menu's range. The room is well-kept and runs a full bar alongside the food program, which gives it more flexibility than the name suggests. Service is friendly; pace can be leisurely.

What to orderBacon sandwichCaramel friesVegan sandwich Call Directions Scored from the full review record 1148 S 11th St, Philadelphia, PA 19147 · (267) 222-0084
12 Live! Casino & Hotel Philadelphia Yelp

Live! Casino & Hotel Philadelphia

American · Philadelphia · $$
Insider Score2.5

Live! Casino and Hotel Philadelphia sits near the sports complex in South Philadelphia and functions primarily as a hospitality property for event travelers and overnight guests. The prime rib and seafood options anchor the dining side; the steak is the high-end play. Free parking and attentive hotel staff appear consistently in the record. For visitors in town for a Broad Street Run or a stadium event, the convenience is the point.

What to orderPrime ribSeafood buffetSteak Call Directions Scored from the full review record 900 Packer Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19148 · (833) 472-5483
What to know before choosing a restaurant

American in Philadelphia: 1. Zahav · 2. The Dandelion · 3. Yards Brewing Company · 4. The Continental Mid-town · 5. McGillin's Olde Ale House. Addresses, prices and what to order.

Philadelphia's American table runs from the BYOB counter on East Passyunk to the corner diner in South Philly, from a century-old ale house to a James Beard-tier kitchen that redefined what this city could do. The twelve rooms here span that range. Bring your own bottle where the sign says so, and let the cooking speak.

Tours in Philadelphia Food tours

Frequently asked

How does the Insider Score work, and does any restaurant pay to be listed?
The Insider Score aggregates public review data and applies editorial weighting for consistency and volume. No restaurant pays to appear on Top of Philly, and no restaurant pays to improve its score. The list is editorially independent.
Which of these American restaurants near me are good for a BYOB dinner in Philadelphia?
Zahav operates as a full-service room with its own beverage program rather than a BYOB, but Philadelphia's broader BYOB culture, especially on East Passyunk, means many neighborhood spots nearby welcome a bottle from home. Check the individual restaurant's current policy before arriving. The Insider Score reflects overall quality, not BYOB status specifically.
Are any of these spots good for large groups?
Yards Brewing Company, McGillin's Olde Ale House, Helium Comedy Club, and Live! Casino and Hotel Philadelphia all show up in the record as group-friendly rooms. Helium in particular structures itself around groups by design. For Zahav, reservations for larger parties require advance planning.
What is the best time to visit McGillin's Olde Ale House?
McGillin's runs a full lunch and dinner service, and the review record suggests a Friday lunch visit offers a seat at the bar without the full evening crowd. The room decorates for holidays throughout the year, so the experience shifts depending on when you go. The Insider Score reflects performance across time, not a single visit.
ƒ

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

About the writer
Margaret Donnelly
Chief Critic

Margaret Donnelly is Top of Philly's chief critic, covering the BYOB scene, the chef-driven and James Beard tier, and where the city's dining is headed. Analysis is built from the public review record, not press dinners.

Five rooms, every Friday.

The new opening, the sleeper the score just flagged, and the one room worth booking this week. Free.

Get the Tip Sheet →