Philadelphia / About / How We Work

How we work.

Every restaurant on Top of Philly carries one number, the Insider Score, calibrated to Philadelphia and never for sale. This page explains how to read it.

9.9/10
The Insider Score Exceptional · Calibrated to Philadelphia · Never for sale

The Insider Score

Every restaurant we cover carries an Insider Score: a single number from 0 to 10, calibrated to Philadelphia. Higher is better. The top-ranked room in the city sets the top of the scale, so a 9.5 here means the best Philadelphia has, not a claim about any other city.

The score is not a copy of another site's star average and not one critic's single meal. It reads how a kitchen has performed over time and whether it still holds that standard today.

Never for sale. No restaurant can buy a score, a place on a list or a position in a ranking. Advertising on this site is labeled as advertising and has no effect on any score.

The scale

Insider Scores are calibrated per city. The highest-ranked room in Philadelphia sets the top of the scale at 9.9, and everything below scales to that anchor.

We do this because every city's dining scene has its own ceiling. Forcing one global scale would either flatten smaller markets into the sixes and sevens or inflate the biggest ones until every city looked the same. Per-city calibration tells the truer story: this is the best room in this town, ranked against the rooms it actually competes with. A 9.9 in Philadelphia is the best Philadelphia has. It is not a claim about any other city.

Corrections

Data ages. Restaurants close, change chefs, move rooms. If you spot an error, stale hours, a closed room, a factual mistake in a guide, email the desk and we will fix it. Substantive corrections are logged in the open: the Updated date on the guide changes, and the entry is revised. We do not silently edit published work.

The desk

Here is who writes the lists.

S
Sal Lombardi
Food Editor

Sal Lombardi covers the Philadelphia sandwich and the South Philly Italian-American table for Top of Philly: cheesesteaks, roast pork, hoagies, the Italian Market, and the red-gravy institutions.

M
Margaret Donnelly
Chief Critic

Margaret Donnelly is Top of Philly's chief critic, covering the BYOB scene, the chef-driven and James Beard tier, and where the city's dining is headed. Analysis is built from the public review record, not press dinners.

J
Jordan Pike
Neighborhoods Editor, Top of Philly

Jordan Pike covers Philadelphia's neighborhoods for Top of Philly: Fishtown, Northern Liberties, Fairmount, Manayunk, the new-restaurant zone, breweries, and the independents that anchor a block.

L
Linh Nguyen
Global Editor

Linh Nguyen covers Philadelphia's immigrant and global table for Top of Philly: the Washington Avenue Vietnamese corridor, the Italian Market's Mexican kitchens, Chinatown, and the Cambodian, West African, and South Asian rooms across the region.

D
Dana Brooks
Suburbs Editor

Dana Brooks covers the Greater Philadelphia suburbs for Top of Philly: the Main Line, King of Prussia, and the South Jersey BYOB towns of Collingswood, Haddonfield, and Cherry Hill, out to Wilmington.

Unsigned analysis runs under a shared byline, the Top Rated Editorial Team. Signed work carries the editor's pen name. Top of Philly is published by Top Rated Network LLC.

A new place to try.

The Tip Sheet brings restaurant recommendations to your inbox.