Philadelphia / Guides / Where to Eat the Best New American

Where to Eat the Best New American in Philadelphia.

8 restaurants, what to order, and the details to help you choose your next meal.

Where to Eat the Best New American in Philadelphia (2026)
8 restaurants · 1 areaCompare the restaurants

Find your Where to Eat the Best New American restaurant.

Showing all 8 restaurants in ranking order.

About Where to Eat the Best New American restaurants in Philadelphia

Philadelphia's new-American table has never been one thing. It runs from Greg Vernick's wood-grilled precision in Rittenhouse to a BYOB brunch spot in Point Breeze where you bring the bottle and the kitchen handles the rest. The eleven rooms here cover that full range: tasting-menu ambition, neighborhood reliability, and a few spots that earn their place on any serious city list without needing a publicist to say so.

Compare all 8 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreWhat to order
01 Talula's GardenPhiladelphia$$$9.8Cheddar chive biscuits
02 Vernick Food & DrinkPhiladelphia$$$$9.5Roasted Amish chicken
03 The Love.Philadelphia$$$9.1Lemon poppy pancakes
04 Friday Saturday SundayPhiladelphia$$$$9.1Gnocchi
05 Standard TapPhiladelphia$$4.8Burger
06 Southwark RestaurantPhiladelphia$$$5.5Seasonal small plates
07 Square 1682Philadelphia$$4.4Philly Special
08 KiddoPhiladelphia5.4Mushroom fondue

8 restaurants · In guide order

01

Talula's Garden

New American · Philadelphia · $$$ · № 2 on the ListBack to filters

9.8Insider Score
Talula's GardenYelp

Garden Dining on Washington Square

The pesto lemon ricotta appetizer arrives warm, which catches first-timers off guard in the best way, and the scallop and shrimp risotto holds up as the anchor of the dinner menu. Brunch draws a crowd to the garden, and the outdoor seating is the reason regulars return through the warm months. The bar and interior hold their own when the garden fills. Reservations are advisable; the room books on reputation.

Talula's Garden on West Washington Square is the room many diners name when they want a long, unhurried dinner. Plants fill both the indoor and outdoor spaces, and the menu rotates, printed fresh each day so corrections can be made. Sourcing is local and the hosts are warm. One diner without a reservation was still given a good seat, though most advise booking.

The meal often begins with freshly baked cheddar chive biscuits. Diners then order the roasted chicken, gnocchi, shrimp risotto, steak, salmon and beet salad. Brunch has its own favorites, including chai donuts, deviled eggs and pancakes, and chicken and waffles also appears on the table.

Practical notes: birthdays and anniversaries fill the reservation book, and brunch is busy. Parking in the area takes effort, so allow extra time. Service gets praise on most visits, though a few diners report a crowded table or a slower server. The menu rotates, so ask about the day's offerings.

Insider tip

Reserve ahead for dinner or brunch, since the room fills for birthdays and anniversaries.

What to order

Cheddar chive biscuits, Roasted chicken, Gnocchi

HoursMon - Fri: 5:00 PM - 10:00 PMSat: 4:00 PM - 10:00 PMSun: 10:00 AM - 2:00 PM, 4:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Address210 W Washington Square
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Restaurant Reservations Call Directions
Map showing Talula's Garden© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Cheddar chive biscuits

Served warm at the start of the meal, they are the first thing diners recall afterward.

Roasted chicken

Tender and well seasoned, it is the main course diners recommend most often.

Gnocchi

Soft and rich, the gnocchi are a favorite among diners who skip meat.

02

Vernick Food & Drink

New American · Philadelphia · $$$$ · № 6 on the ListBack to filters

9.5Insider Score
Vernick Food & DrinkYelp

Polished Dinners on Walnut Street

Greg Vernick's Rittenhouse room is among the city's national-class addresses, and the cooking earns that standing dish by dish. The beef tartare and seasonal vegetable toast read as complementary courses, not afterthoughts, and the wood-grilled fish is the plate most worth anchoring an order around. The room works as a pre-theater stop before the Academy of Music. Expect top-end pricing and service that justifies it.

Vernick Food & Drink on Walnut Street is a dinner restaurant where diners say the service is polished from the first moment. A host opens the front door, and tables downstairs or at the bar are offered when guests arrive early. Seats at the kitchen counter let diners watch the line work.

The roasted Amish chicken and the blue crab are the dishes that come up most, along with salmon, lamb, pasta and a radish salad. Shrimp toast and a mushroom pasta make good openers. Wine matters here, and diners mention the list often. One regular says the meal felt worth the price and that the staff made the night.

Practical notes: birthdays and anniversaries are common, so reserve ahead. Some diners find a few dishes heavy on salt, so mention preferences early. Tables can be close together. Bar seats may open late, so ask the host about the wait. Cocktails are well liked.

Insider tip

Ask for a seat at the kitchen counter or bar, and tell the server about seasoning preferences.

What to order

Roasted Amish chicken, Blue crab, Shrimp toast

HoursMon: ClosedTue - Thu: 4:45 PM - 9:30 PMFri - Sat: 4:45 PM - 10:00 PMSun: Closed
Address2031 Walnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Call Directions
Map showing Vernick Food & Drink© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Roasted Amish chicken

Juicy and carefully cooked, it is the main dish diners say they would order again.

Blue crab

Light and sweet, it is a first course that diners praise for its clean flavors.

Shrimp toast

Crisp and savory, it is a popular starter before the larger plates.

03

The Love.

New American · Philadelphia · $$$ · № 11 on the ListBack to filters

9.1Insider Score
The Love.Yelp

Brunch and Dinner near Rittenhouse

The avocado toast and eggs benedict handle the brunch load reliably, and the burger gives the menu a lunch anchor. Walk-ins who miss a reservation do well at the bar. The room pulls pre-airport traffic with enough regularity that the kitchen runs at a steady pace on Saturday mornings. The space itself earns immediate goodwill on arrival. Casual pricing for the neighborhood, with table service that stays friendly under volume.

The Love on South 18th Street is a large, beautiful dining room near Rittenhouse Square. Servers are consistently warm, and the restaurant is a go-to for anniversaries and birthdays. One diner who asked to sit outside was given a booth down the block near the park. Another received complimentary bubbly and an apology after a short wait.

Brunch is the busiest meal. Lemon poppy pancakes and hush puppies lead the morning, and the biscuits, salmon and mushroom soup follow. At dinner, shrimp, ravioli, fried chicken, risotto and rigatoni with short ribs draw praise. The cocktail list pairs well with the long evenings.

Practical notes: reservations are close to required, particularly at brunch, and even a reservation can mean a short wait when the room is full. Some diners found a salad or the ravioli too salty, and a few reported small slips in service. The pace is relaxed, so allow time. Dinner is a good option for a date.

Insider tip

Reserve for brunch, since the whole room is full and the line at the door grows.

What to order

Lemon poppy pancakes, Shrimp, Fried chicken

HoursMon - Fri: 11:30 AM - 2:00 PM, 5:00 PM - 10:00 PMSat - Sun: 10:00 AM - 2:00 PM, 5:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Address130 S 18th St
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Restaurant Reservations Call Directions
Map showing The Love.© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Lemon poppy pancakes

Fluffy and lightly sweet, they are the brunch order most diners call a favorite.

Shrimp

Seasoned well and served warm, it is a popular starter or main for groups.

Fried chicken

Crisp and juicy, it is a comfort dish that diners enjoy at dinner.

04

Friday Saturday Sunday

New American · Philadelphia · $$$$ · № 12 on the ListBack to filters

9.1Insider Score
Friday Saturday SundayYelp

Romantic Tasting Menus on 21st

Friday Saturday Sunday runs a tasting menu that, at its best, draws the kind of praise Philadelphians reserve for a short list of rooms. The seasonal vegetable course and house-made pasta are the sections of the menu most consistently cited. Reservations are genuinely difficult to land, and the price point is real. Not every table leaves fully satisfied, but the room sets a high ceiling for new-American ambition in this city.

Friday Saturday Sunday on South 21st Street is a dining room with old world, eclectic decor and hand painted landscape murals under romantic lighting. Diners describe it as relaxed rather than stuffy, with a coordinated team of servers working each table. One solo walk-in on a packed night was treated with real hospitality.

Dinner is a multi course tasting menu, and the cooking has personality. Gnocchi, steak, short ribs, French onion soup, lobster and clams appear in praise from diners. A creamy chicken liver mousse, a herring spaghetti and a corn soup are often described as creative. Vegetarian diners praise a squash appetizer and a beet main shaped like a star.

Practical notes: seats are hard to land on short notice, so reserve early. The wine list is a strength, with cocktails also well regarded. A few diners found the pace slow and the evening costly for the experience, so plan for a long meal. Birthdays and anniversaries are common.

Insider tip

Reserve early, since seats are hard to get, and plan for a relaxed pace.

What to order

Gnocchi, Steak, Short ribs

HoursMon - Tue: ClosedWed - Sun: 4:45 PM - 11:00 PM
Address261 S 21st St
Philadelphia, PA 19103
Restaurant Reservations Call Directions
Map showing Friday Saturday Sunday© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Gnocchi

Delicate and rich, the gnocchi are the pasta dish diners recall most often.

Steak

Cooked precisely and served with thoughtful sides, it is a main that diners praise.

Short ribs

Tender and deeply flavored, the ribs suit diners who want a hearty plate.

05

Standard Tap

New American · Philadelphia · $$Back to filters

4.8Insider Score
Standard TapYelp

Standard Tap is a Northern Liberties pub that runs across two floors, with the bar level on entry and additional seating above. The burger and fries are the reliable order, and the draft beer program is the reason the room stays full. Restaurant week brings in new traffic at $45 for three courses. Saturday nights run crowded; a reservation holds a table without drama. Service is competent, not memorable.

What to order

Burger, Fries, Draft beer

901 N 2nd St, Philadelphia, PA 19123 · (215) 238-0630

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
06

Southwark Restaurant

New American · Philadelphia · $$$Back to filters

5.5Insider Score
Southwark RestaurantYelp

Southwark is built for sharing. The seasonal small plates and charcuterie board travel well across a table, and the room works best when enough people are seated to move through several courses. The craft cocktails are a serious part of the evening, with the bar drawing its own crowd for drinks and lighter bites. Monday wine events have filled the room when the kitchen runs a lighter format. Service reads as attentive.

What to order

Seasonal small plates, Craft cocktails, Charcuterie board

701 S 4th St, Philadelphia, PA 19147 · (267) 930-8538

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
07

Square 1682

New American · Philadelphia · $$Back to filters

4.4Insider Score
Square 1682Yelp

Square 1682 operates as the dining room for a Center City hotel and pulls the weekday lunch and weekend brunch crowd that comes with that position. The Philly Special is a generous portion; the home fries draw mixed notes. Eggs benedict and avocado toast are the safer plays. Walk-in seating is available midweek without much wait. Reliable rather than ambitious, which suits its function as a hotel-adjacent room.

What to order

Philly Special, Avocado toast, Eggs benedict

121 S 17th St, Philadelphia, PA 19103 · (215) 563-5008

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
08

Kiddo

New American · PhiladelphiaBack to filters

5.4Insider Score
KiddoYelp

Kiddo draws date-night traffic to a dining room that reads as considered and quiet. The mushroom fondue is the most-discussed plate, though it divides opinion on portion and execution. The brunch program adds a Sunday reservation crowd, with the front room giving way to a more secluded main dining area. The room is notably dim, which some find atmospheric and others find limiting. The cocktails are taken seriously.

What to order

Mushroom fondue, Brunch cocktail, Seasonal small plates

1138 Pine St, Philadelphia, PA 19107 · (215) 398-3377

Call Directions Scored from the full review record

Where to Eat the Best New American restaurant questions, answered.

Where can I find the best new American restaurants near me in Philadelphia?
This guide covers new-American rooms across Philadelphia and nearby neighborhoods, from Rittenhouse to Point Breeze to Fishtown. Every restaurant listed earned its place based on the Insider Score, a data-driven rating built from the public review record. No restaurant pays to be included.
Which of these restaurants is best for a special-occasion dinner?
Friday Saturday Sunday and Vernick Food and Drink are the two rooms in this guide that operate at the highest level of ambition and price. Both carry strong Insider Scores. Friday Saturday Sunday runs a tasting menu; Vernick anchors around wood-grilled fish and precise seasonal cooking. Either requires advance reservations.
Are any of these restaurants BYOB?
It is one of the more affordable options in this guide and works well for a group brunch. The Insider Score reflects how the room performs, not whether it has a bar program.
How does the Insider Score work, and do restaurants pay to be listed?
The Insider Score is calculated from the public review record across major platforms. No restaurant pays to appear in this guide or any guide on Top of Philly. The rankings reflect the data, not advertising relationships.

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

About the writer
Margaret Donnelly
Chief Critic

Margaret Donnelly is Top of Philly's chief critic, covering the BYOB scene, the chef-driven and James Beard tier, and where the city's dining is headed. Analysis is built from the public review record, not press dinners.

A new place to try.

The Tip Sheet brings restaurant recommendations to your inbox.